Hunt & Live

Q&A · Hunting

What are most common mistakes when selecting broadheads?

April 6, 2026

Quick Answer

Hunters often make mistakes when selecting broadheads, such as choosing the wrong cutting diameter, neglecting flight characteristics, and selecting broadheads based on game species without considering the actual hunting conditions.

Choosing the Right Cutting Diameter

When selecting a broadhead, the cutting diameter is one of the most critical factors. A cutting diameter that is too small may not be effective for larger game, while a cutting diameter that is too large may result in a poor expansion pattern. As a general rule, a 1 3/4" to 2" cutting diameter is suitable for most deer hunting applications, while larger cutting diameters are better suited for larger game such as elk or moose. It’s also worth noting that some broadheads feature interchangeable blades with different cutting diameters, allowing hunters to customize their selection based on the specific game they are hunting.

Considering Flight Characteristics

In addition to the cutting diameter, hunters should also consider the flight characteristics of their broadhead, including its weight, aerodynamics, and penetration depth. A heavier broadhead may be more effective for larger game, but may also be more difficult to control in windy conditions. Hunters should choose a broadhead that balances these factors with their specific hunting needs. For example, a 300-grain broadhead with a high ballistic coefficient may be a good choice for long-range hunting, while a 150-grain broadhead with a low ballistic coefficient may be better suited for close-quarters hunting.

Selecting the Right Type of Broadhead

There are three main types of broadheads: fixed blade, mechanical, and hybrid. Fixed blade broadheads are simple and reliable, but may not penetrate as deeply as other types. Mechanical broadheads are designed to expand upon impact, creating a larger cutting diameter, but may be more prone to mechanical failure. Hybrid broadheads combine the best features of both fixed and mechanical broadheads, offering a balance of penetration and expansion. Hunters should choose the type of broadhead that best suits their specific hunting needs and conditions.

broadhead-selection common mistakes selecting broadheads
Share

Find more answers

Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.