Quick Answer
For catching squirrels in the attic, the best traps are humane, box-style traps baited with peanut butter or hazelnuts, which are effective for 60% to 80% of squirrel removals. Use 2-3 traps initially and place them near common entry points. Check traps at least twice daily.
Choosing the Right Traps
When selecting humane squirrel traps, look for box-style traps specifically designed for this purpose. These traps typically measure 10 inches wide by 7 inches deep by 6 inches tall and have spring-loaded doors that shut when the squirrel enters. They usually come in two styles: one-way and two-way doors. One-way doors allow the squirrel to enter but not exit, while two-way doors allow the squirrel to enter and exit, which can help reduce stress on the animal but may not be as effective.
Baiting and Placement
To increase the effectiveness of your traps, use a strong bait such as peanut butter or hazelnuts on the trigger plate. Place the traps near common entry points, such as vents, chimneys, or holes in the roof. For best results, use 2-3 traps initially and space them about 10 feet apart. Check the traps at least twice daily, as squirrels can be wary of new traps and may take several days to become accustomed to them.
After-Capture Procedures
Once you’ve caught a squirrel, follow local regulations for handling and releasing the animal. Typically, you’ll need to transport the squirrel at least 5 miles from the capture site before releasing it. Before releasing, inspect the squirrel for any injuries or signs of illness. If the squirrel appears injured or ill, consult a local wildlife rehabilitator for advice. After releasing the squirrel, seal any entry points to prevent re-infestation.
Find more answers
Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.