Hunt & Live

Q&A · Hunting

Underwater vs Above Water Fish Hunting: Which Is Better?

April 9, 2026

Quick Answer

Underwater fish hunting is often more challenging and physically demanding than above-water hunting, but it can be more effective for certain species due to the element of surprise and increased accuracy. Above-water hunting, on the other hand, allows for more comfort and control, but may require more patience and skill to make a successful shot.

The Challenge of Underwater Fishing

Underwater fishing requires a specific set of skills, including the ability to hold your breath for extended periods and navigate through the water with ease. To increase your chances of success, use a mask or snorkel that provides a clear view of the water and allows you to remain submerged for up to 2 minutes. Additionally, invest in a specialized underwater bow or spear gun that can be cocked and fired while underwater.

Choosing the Right Equipment

When selecting equipment for underwater fishing, look for items that are lightweight and compact, such as a bow with a length of 20-22 inches and a poundage of 30-40 pounds. This will allow for a comfortable and accurate shot while minimizing the risk of water pressure affecting the bow’s performance. Consider also using a specialized underwater arrow or spear tip that is designed for use in water, with a weight of 100-120 grains and a diameter of 3/8 inch.

Tips for Successful Underwater Hunting

To increase your chances of success when hunting underwater, focus on selecting a location with clear visibility and a high concentration of fish. Use a combination of stealth and camouflage to approach your target undetected, and aim for a shot that will result in a quick and humane kill. Consider also practicing your underwater skills in a controlled environment before attempting a real hunt, to build your endurance and confidence in the water.

archery-underwater-shooting underwater above water fish hunting
Share

Find more answers

Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.