Quick Answer
Short Answer: For elk hunting, arrow weight is more crucial than speed to ensure deep penetration and prevent arrow breakage, as elk possess thick hide and massive bone structure.
Penetration Matters
When it comes to hunting elk, penetration is key. A heavier arrow, typically weighing between 350-450 grains, is more effective at deep penetration than a faster, lighter arrow. This is because elk have thick hide, often exceeding 1/2 inch in some areas, which requires a substantial amount of kinetic energy to penetrate. A heavier arrow can deliver this energy, while a lighter arrow may not.
Real-World Example
For instance, a 300-grain arrow traveling at 250 feet per second (fps) may not provide the same level of penetration as a 400-grain arrow traveling at 240 fps. In this scenario, the heavier arrow’s increased kinetic energy allows it to penetrate deeper, despite being slower.
Arrow Design Considerations
While arrow speed is important for shorter ranges, the importance of arrow weight and design increases as the distance increases. For elk hunting, a broadhead designed for deep penetration, such as a 1 3/4-inch cutting diameter, is more critical than arrow speed. This is because elk are often shot at longer ranges, typically exceeding 50 yards, where arrow weight and penetration become more crucial factors.
Find more answers
Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.