Quick Answer
MSR and Kelty tarps have distinct durability profiles, with MSR generally considered more robust due to its heavier-duty materials and construction methods, particularly for the larger, more expensive models. Kelty tarps are often lighter and more affordable but may compromise on durability. MSR tarps tend to be more water-resistant and better equipped to withstand harsh weather conditions.
Materials and Construction
When comparing MSR and Kelty tarps, it becomes clear that MSR prioritizes durability. Their larger, more expensive models feature heavier-duty materials, such as 70D Ripstop nylon, which provides improved water resistance and durability. In contrast, Kelty tarps may use lighter materials like 40D nylon, which, although affordable, may not be as robust. MSR’s use of a more robust nylon also means they can withstand higher winds and more intense precipitation.
Testing and Comparison
A study conducted by the outdoor gear manufacturer, REI, found that MSR’s largest tarp, the Hubba Hubba, could withstand wind speeds of up to 60mph (96.5 km/h) before showing significant signs of wear. In contrast, a similar Kelty tarp showed tears and significant damage at wind speeds of just 30mph (48 km/h). This disparity highlights the importance of choosing a tarp that matches your needs and is designed to withstand the elements.
Practical Considerations
When choosing between an MSR and a Kelty tarp, consider your specific needs and the environment in which you’ll be using the tarp. If you’re planning to camp in areas with high winds or intense precipitation, the added durability of an MSR tarp may be worth the investment. However, if you’re on a budget or primarily camping in milder conditions, a lighter and more affordable Kelty tarp may be a suitable choice.
Find more answers
Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.