Hunt & Live

Q&A · Hunting

Troubleshooting Broadhead Issues: Why Did My Arrow Not Penetrate?

April 9, 2026

Quick Answer

A broadhead's failure to penetrate may be due to incorrect broadhead selection, improper arrow flight, or issues with the point's design or sharpness.

Broadhead Selection and Arrow Flight Issues

When selecting a broadhead, consider the weight and design suitable for your target species and hunting style. A heavy broadhead may not penetrate well in lighter skinned game, while a lightweight broadhead may not provide enough kinetic energy for larger game. Ensure your arrow is properly tuned and the point is securely attached to minimize damage from shock waves and loss of kinetic energy. A consistent arrow flight, with minimal vibration and oscillation, is crucial for proper penetration. Aim for an arrow speed of at least 250 feet per second (fps) for optimal penetration.

Point Design and Sharpness Issues

A broadhead’s design plays a significant role in its ability to penetrate. Look for mechanical broadheads with a minimum of 2 inches of cutting diameter and a 3-inch minimum width for maximum penetration. A broadhead’s sharpness is also crucial; a sharp point will slice through the target material more effectively, reducing the likelihood of broadhead failure. Regularly inspect and maintain your broadheads’ sharpness by honing the cutting edges every 3-5 shots.

Real-World Solutions

In real-world situations, consider the following solutions:

  • If using a 2-blade broadhead, try switching to a 3-blade or 4-blade design for improved penetration.
  • If the broadhead failed to penetrate, inspect the point’s integrity and replace it if necessary.
  • Consider adjusting your hunting technique to account for the broadhead’s limitations, such as using a smaller target species or increasing the kinetic energy of your arrow.
best-broadheads-for-whitetail troubleshooting broadhead issues arrow penetrate
Share

Find more answers

Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.