Hunt & Live

Q&A · Survival

Situations Where Figure-Eight Knots Might Fail?

April 5, 2026

Quick Answer

Situations where figure-eight knots might fail include when subjected to sudden or high-force jerks, such as when a fish pulls against a fishing line, or when used with thin or damaged rope. Additionally, improper tying or inadequate tightening can compromise the knot's reliability. Tightening the knot too much can also be counterproductive.

Factors Contributing to Failure

The figure-eight, also known as the Flemish knot, is a reliable stopper knot when tied correctly. However, several factors can contribute to its failure. One key factor is the type of rope used – thin or damaged ropes are more susceptible to knot failure. Another critical aspect is the size of the knot relative to the rope diameter. A figure-eight knot should be at least 5 to 7 times the rope diameter in circumference to ensure it doesn’t slip or jam.

Testing and Tying Techniques

To minimize the risk of figure-eight knot failure, it’s essential to properly test and tighten the knot. This can be achieved by pulling the standing part of the rope in a direction opposite to the direction of the load. A minimum of 5-7 full turns of the standing part around the standing part, with each turn crossing over the previous one, will create a secure knot. When tightening the knot, use a steady, consistent force to avoid over-tightening.

Rope and Load Considerations

When using a figure-eight knot for load-bearing applications, consider the maximum load capacity of the rope and the knot itself. A general rule of thumb is to limit the load to 90% of the rope’s breaking strength. This ensures the knot is not subjected to excessive stress, which can lead to failure. Additionally, consider the type of load being applied – sudden or high-force jerks can still compromise the knot even if it’s tied correctly.

knots-figure-eight-family situations figureeight knots might fail
Share

Find more answers

Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.