Quick Answer
Carbon arrows are generally more durable than aluminum arrows due to their resistance to bending and impact damage, but they can be more prone to breakage under heavy loads. Aluminum arrows, on the other hand, are more prone to bending and deforming but can withstand greater impact forces before breaking.
Material Comparison
When it comes to arrow durability, the choice between carbon and aluminum largely depends on the type of hunting you’ll be doing. For high-impact hunting with heavy draw weights or long-range shots, aluminum arrows may be a better choice. This is because aluminum arrows can withstand greater impact forces before breaking, often up to 120 pounds per square inch (psi). However, they can be more prone to bending and deforming, which can affect their aerodynamics and accuracy.
Arrow Spine Selection
Arrow spine selection is critical for maintaining arrow durability, regardless of material. A spine is a measure of an arrow’s stiffness, with lower spines indicating greater flexibility. For hunting with high-impact shots, a stiffer arrow with a higher spine (typically 6-8) is recommended to reduce the risk of bending and breakage. Conversely, for shorter-range shots with less impact, a more flexible arrow with a lower spine (typically 2-4) can be used to improve accuracy.
FOC Balance and Arrow Weight
FOC (Forward Of Center) balance is also crucial for arrow durability. A well-balanced arrow with a consistent FOC will be less prone to wobbling and twisting during flight, which can put excessive stress on the arrow and increase the risk of breakage. To achieve optimal FOC balance, hunters should aim for a balance point of between 20-30% of the arrow’s overall length from the rear. Additionally, using arrows with a consistent weight and balance will also help to reduce the risk of breakage and improve overall accuracy.
Find more answers
Browse the full Q&A library by topic, or jump back to the topic this question belongs to.